Overlapping Pickets vs. Side-by-Side Pickets: What’s the Difference?

When planning a fence installation, most people focus on material and height, but picket layout plays a big role in how a fence looks, performs, and ages over time. Two of the most common styles are overlapping pickets and side-by-side pickets. While they may seem similar at first glance, the differences matter.

Side-by-Side Pickets: Clean and Traditional

Side-by-side pickets are installed edge-to-edge, creating a flat, uniform surface. This is the most common layout for privacy fences.

Pros:

• Clean, simple appearance

• Uses fewer materials, which can reduce cost

• Faster installation

• Works well for standard residential fencing

  
  

Cons:

• Small gaps can appear over time as materials expand, contract, or shrink

• Less effective at blocking wind, noise, and sight-lines

• Can feel less substantial on long runs or taller fences

  
  

Side-by-side pickets are a solid choice for homeowners who want a straightforward look and a budget-friendly solution.

Overlapping Pickets: Stronger and More Private

Overlapping pickets, often called board-on-board, are installed with each picket partially covering the next. This creates depth, texture, and full coverage from every angle.

Pros:

• No visible gaps, even as materials shift

• Increased privacy from both sides of the fence

• Better wind resistance and overall rigidity

• More dimensional, high-end appearance

Cons:

• Requires more material, increasing cost

• Slightly longer installation time

• Heavier fence panels may require stronger posts

  
  

Overlapping pickets are ideal for properties where privacy, durability, and curb appeal are top priorities.

Performance Over Time

One key difference between these styles shows up years after installation. Side-by-side fences can develop gaps as boards naturally move with moisture and temperature changes. Overlapping pickets compensate for that movement, maintaining coverage and alignment longer.

In areas with strong winds or fluctuating weather, overlapping pickets often outperform side-by-side designs.

Which Option Is Right for You?

Choose side-by-side pickets if:

• You want a classic look at a lower cost

• The fence is decorative or semi-private

• You’re installing in a low-wind, stable climate

  
  

Choose overlapping pickets if:

• Privacy is a top concern

• You want a fence that feels more solid and substantial

• Long-term performance matters more than upfront savings

  
  

Final Thoughts

Both picket styles have their place in fence installations. Side-by-side pickets offer simplicity and affordability, while overlapping pickets deliver maximum privacy, strength, and longevity. The right choice depends on your priorities, your environment, and how you want your fence to perform over time.